Although little
Sandy Denny material was released prior to her first album as part of
Fairport Convention (1969's
What We Did on Our Holidays), quite a few pre-
Fairport recordings of the singer's survive, though they usually weren't made in the most technically sophisticated settings. This CD, recorded in the Glasgow home of folk singer
Alex Campbell on August 5, 1967, was salvaged from a cassette and issued in 2011, when interest in
Denny's work had escalated to a point where even documents of rather lo-fi quality held enough interest to merit a commercial release. This is clearly a recording for serious
Denny fans because of those technical limitations; even some of the other home recordings from the time that have found both official and bootleg release boast superior sound. It should also be noted that some of the songs don't feature
Denny as sole vocalist, with
Alex Campbell and Patsy Campbell (and even their two young boys) singing along with her on the least interesting tracks. The majority of it does spotlight
Denny, however, and will be of interest to hardcore devotees, owing both to her habitually excellent singing and the presence of some songs not available in other versions. Among the most obscure are the traditional "The Leaves of Life," likely learned from a
Martin Carthy album; the similarly melancholy 16th century traditional tune "Balulalow"; "Trouble in Mind," and "Fairy Tale Lullaby," which
John Martyn did on his first album. There are a few items more familiar to
Denny followers, and these are the most enjoyable on the CD, and include Jackson Frank's "Milk and Honey"; "Who Knows Where the Time Goes," perhaps her most famous composition (and the only original number on this collection), and "She Moves Through the Fair," which she'd sing in a much more fully produced version with
Fairport on
What We Did on Our Holidays. Even if this falls on the "for-fans-only" side of archival releases,
Denny's singing (and its suitability for haunting melodies in particular) can't be faulted, and it's sensitively packaged, with liner notes by
the Strawbs'
Dave Cousins and annotation for each track.
–
Richie Unterberger, Rovi